Have you ever found yourself staring at the menu, unable to make a decision for your entree? That is a huge problem at these Whitewater establishments because everything just sounds so good! Fortunately for you, we’ve picked out our favorite meals all across Whitewater so you can sit back, and enjoy with no stress. These 5 mouthwatering meals are the ones that leave us licking our fingers and planning our next visit.
A meal at the Kraus House at The Fuzzy Pig is more than worth the drive to this rustic farm just south of town. This farm to table restaurant serves culinary masterpieces created with ingredients sourced from farmer’s markets and nearby farms. One of the most sought after dishes is the braised pork shank. A hand-seasoned shank is slow-braised for hours until the meat becomes tender and melt-in-your-mouth delicious. The shank is then oven seared to seal in the flavor, finished with demi-glace, and is served with the classic combination of mashed potatoes, seasonal vegetables, and your choice of soup or salad.
Nothing warms you up like a delicious bowl of pasta from Whitewater’s favorite Italian eatery. You may be tempted by the creamy and fragrant alfredo or the classic bucatini with meatballs, but denying yourself the pleasure of their Farfalle Mare e Monti is almost a sin. Fresh shrimp and calamari are tossed with sun-dried tomatoes, artichoke hearts, and pasta, then dressed in a flavorful creamy vodka sauce. Every bite of this dish teases your flavor palate and allows you to fall in love with the dish all over again.
Cozumel Mexican Restaurant has been praised by locals and visitors alike for their incredibly authentic and delicious entrees. The secret? Everything is made from scratch with the freshest ingredients. You can taste the quality in their complimentary homemade chips and salsa, but the flavor doesn’t stop there. While you can’t go wrong with anything on their menu, their tacos are absolutely to-die-for. The meat is perfectly seasoned and packs a load of flavor in every bite. Grab a set of three and you’ll be smiling in no time.
A perfect fish and chips platter is difficult to find. The cod has to fresh and juicy while the breading on the outside has to be crispy and flavorful without being too thick or flaky. 841 Brewhouse has mastered their fried cod. Fresh, crispy, flavorful. You can order their beer-battered North Atlantic Cod with your choice of sides so you can create a classic fish n’ chip entree with french fries and coleslaw or warm up with a cup of house-made soup and a baked potato. Pro Tip: Ask for a side of their Signature 841 Dippin’ Sauce. You’ll be licking your fingers clean after this incredible meal.
The Black Sheep has a rotating menu that could keep you coming back time after time to try their seasonal twists on classic dishes. They do carry a sampling of ‘Forever Entrees’ also known as ‘entrees that are so good that if they were to go away, riots would ensue’. Top of the list is the famed Chef’s Lamb Ravioli. House-made ravioli is filled with lamb sausage from Pinn-Oak Farms just south of town and topped with a fresh rosemary cream sauce to bring out the earthy taste of succulent lamb. Creamy, filling, and absolutely incredible. You won’t have to worry about choosing the wrong thing at any of these Whitewater establishments because there really is no bad dish! Try a couple of our favorite meals around town and let us know which is your favorite of the bunch. Ready to dine your way through Whitewater, WI? Book a stay at the lovelyHamilton House Bed & Breakfast in downtown Whitewater, just minutes from Kettle Moraine State Park.